Top 5 Surveys & Feedback Calls for Insurance Agencies

Insurance clients rarely reach out until something goes wrong, which is exactly why surveys and feedback calls matter so much in this business. Research from SurveyNinja notes that 63% of insurance clients who switch say they never heard from their agent between renewals, and J.D. Power's 2026 studies keep pointing at claims handling and the renewal window as the two moments that decide whether a policyholder stays. Email surveys help, but they quietly miss most of your book: Contact Babel research cited by Cresta puts post-call survey response rates at roughly 25-35%, and respondents skew toward the extremes. A phone call gets you a real conversation, a tone of voice, and a follow-up question when an answer is vague. The trick is doing it at scale without blowing up your payroll or your compliance posture. We compared five options for running surveys and feedback calls at insurance agencies, from managed AI calling services to live-agent call centers and self-serve survey platforms. Here's what we found.

#1 My AI Call Center — Calling starts at 9¢ per connected minute, tiered by volume, with the rate locked for the campaign. Most campaigns add a one-time setup and a flat monthly management fee, both quoted before launch. The first campaign review is free.

My AI Call Center is a done-for-you managed outbound calling service owned by AIQ Labs, based in Halifax, Nova Scotia with an operating base in Austin, Texas. Instead of selling you software to figure out, you buy campaigns that their team runs for you, each scoped around one clear goal and quoted in full before anything launches. For an insurance agency, that means a Surveys & Feedback campaign aimed at a specific outcome: post-claims satisfaction, pre-renewal pulse checks, or onboarding check-ins for new policyholders. You tell them what you need the call to accomplish, they review your list and consent records, you approve the script and escalation path, and then the calls run in approved calling windows. Nothing launches until you sign off. What separates it from a typical survey tool is list discipline and honesty in reporting. My AI Call Center only calls approved, permissioned, or reviewed lists, and they check list source and consent records before any campaign starts. Bought lists without clear permission records get flagged, and in most cases declined. They tell you plainly if a list won't support the campaign before you spend anything. On the reporting side, they commit to no invented numbers: you get a named outcome report with disposition codes (confirmed, qualified, renewed, opted out, no answer), per-call notes, and follow-up requests routed back into the CRM and scheduling tools you already run. Hot leads can transfer to your team live or land in your CRM. Compliance is treated as a feature, not fine print. AI voices are handled as artificial voices under the TCPA, with prior express consent required, state-specific quiet hours honored, and AI disclosure on every call. Recipients can ask whether the call is AI-assisted, request a human, or opt out with keywords like STOP and REVOKE, and opt-outs are logged and honored immediately. DNC requests carry across all campaigns into your DNC records. If your agency has a regulated book of business, that posture matters.

Best for: Multi-location insurance agencies and multi-line brokerages (typically 1-200+ staff) that want structured survey and feedback calls run against permissioned policyholder lists without hiring more callers.

#2 TeleDirect — Contact for pricing

TeleDirect is an established call center services provider offering outbound survey programs run by live agents. According to their website, their survey services capture feedback the moment an interaction ends, when details and emotions are still clear, and they emphasize that immediacy as the core value of phone-based feedback. For insurance agencies, that translates to post-claims calls and service follow-ups conducted by trained agents rather than automated systems. Their approach leans on human conversations. TeleDirect highlights that its agents are trained in active listening and can detect tone and adapt to a customer's responses in ways automated calls can't, which can produce richer qualitative feedback on claims experiences. They also offer a multi-channel mix: phone surveys for depth, email for cost-effective reach, and SMS for quick one-question checks with high open rates. Their site notes that survey tools are compatible with existing platforms used in healthcare and insurance, and that their feedback surveys meet ISO standards and satisfy HIPAA requirements. TeleDirect shares a customer example on their site: a healthcare client used outbound surveys to identify onboarding difficulties, and changes based on that data led to a 5% improvement in customer retention, which for that client meant retaining 1,000 additional customers generating over $1 million in revenue. It's a live-agent model, so expect costs that reflect human labor rather than per-minute AI rates.

Best for: Agencies that want human-conducted survey calls and have the budget for a live-agent outsourcing model.

#3 Zonka Feedback — Contact for pricing

Zonka Feedback is a VoC and survey platform that publishes insurance-specific guidance and positions itself for carriers, brokers, and insurtech teams collecting feedback across the policyholder journey. According to their website, they evaluated their own platform against five insurance criteria: insurance analytics depth, omnichannel coverage, real-time alerting, integration with claims and CRM systems, and compliance certifications. For insurance specifically, Zonka emphasizes feedback at the moments that matter: FNOL, claims status updates, settlement, and the renewal window. Their content notes that feedback collected at those touchpoints, rather than a single post-claim satisfaction survey, is what predicts renewal decisions. Feature-wise, their platform supports omnichannel collection including email, SMS, website widgets, and kiosks, plus AI-powered analytics for sentiment, themes, and impact scoring. Real-time alerts and dashboards can be broken out by location, agent, and team, with closed-loop tools to assign and resolve feedback issues. Zonka works with insurance organizations including SPB Benelux, which manages feedback across 40 million policyholders and more than 611,000 annual claims, and CAC Specialty, a top-40 U.S. insurance broker. It's a software platform, so your team builds and runs the surveys, which is a different model from a managed calling service but a strong fit if you want multi-channel coverage under one roof.

Best for: Agencies and carriers that want a self-serve, multi-channel feedback platform with insurance-specific analytics rather than outsourced calling.

#4 SurveyNinja — Free to get started; paid plans available (contact or see site for current tiers)

SurveyNinja offers survey templates and workflows built specifically for insurance agencies, brokerages, and independent agents. According to their website, their insurance use cases include claims experience ratings, agent performance tracking, policyholder NPS, onboarding feedback, pre-renewal satisfaction checks, and coverage review feedback. That maps well to how an agency actually operates, since it treats the renewal window as a retention tool rather than just a measurement exercise. Their insurance feature set includes a post-claims auto-survey triggered when a claim closes, agent-level analytics that compare NPS and CSAT by agent, policy type, and branch, and a low-rating escalation that alerts a branch manager instantly when a policyholder rates below 3 stars. Renewal prediction signals flag at-risk policyholders from low NPS scores so your team can reach out proactively. They also support agency management system integration via webhook with Applied Epic, Hawksoft, or AMS360 for automated survey delivery. SurveyNinja publishes a case study on their site: an independent agency with 2,400 policyholders ran pre-renewal SMS surveys 60 days before each renewal, flagged 34 at-risk clients, and personal outreach saved 29 of them, retaining $87K in annual premiums. Overall renewal rate rose from 82% to 94% over eight months. Those are their numbers, not independently verified, but the workflow they describe is sound and the agency-system integrations are a genuine plus.

Best for: Independent agencies and brokerages that want affordable, template-driven digital surveys tied to their agency management system.

#5 AnswerHero — Contact for pricing

AnswerHero is a phone answering and survey service that blends live agents with an AI receptionist. According to their website, their survey feature lets them ask your callers questions and record answers in a form or web survey, with calls handled by a live agent, an AI receptionist, or a hybrid of both. They note that most businesses let AI run the bulk of survey volume since the questions are straightforward and repeatable, which keeps costs down. Their model is inbound-first but extends to survey collection: they describe a six-step process from defining what you want to know, through asking unambiguous questions, to recording data in a way that supports interpretation and then acting on patterns. Their AI receptionists run the same script consistently call after call without fatigue or variation, which matters for survey data quality since inconsistent delivery is a common source of noise. They also cite the general advantage that phone surveys get better response rates than web polls because there's a polite voice on the line and nothing to fill out. AnswerHero markets 24/7 coverage, bilingual human and AI receptionists, and no contracts or hidden fees. For an insurance agency, the fit is strongest for post-call and inbound-attached surveys: capturing feedback from callers who already engaged with your office, rather than large structured outbound campaigns across your whole book.

Best for: Small agencies that want an answering service with survey capture built in, especially for post-call feedback from inbound callers.

The right choice depends on what kind of feedback program you're running. If you want structured survey and feedback calls across your policyholder base without hiring a bigger call center, My AI Call Center's managed model is hard to beat: campaigns scoped around one clear goal, list and consent review before you spend anything, outcomes routed into your CRM, and per-minute calling that starts at 9¢ with the rate locked for the campaign. If you specifically want human-conducted interviews, TeleDirect offers a live-agent alternative. If digital-first surveys tied to your agency management system fit better, SurveyNinja and Zonka Feedback both have credible insurance-specific offerings. Whatever you pick, the timing advice is consistent across the research: survey at claims resolution, at onboarding, and 30 to 60 days before renewal, because those are the moments that decide retention. Ready to scope a survey or feedback campaign for your agency? Start with a free campaign review at myaicallcenter.app and tell them what you need the call to accomplish.

Frequently asked questions